How to Evaluate an Expired Domain Name

A friend recently asked me about a domain name he was thinking of buying. He mentioned that one of the websites he owns and has developed is the name of a city: and he noticed that there is a ‘related’ domain name that is for sale. It used to be on the same topic of the website that he owns, and he wanted to know if he should purchase it and redirect it to his current website. How should you evaluate an expired domain name?

checklist

If you’re fortunate enough to find another domain name or what I call an “expired domain name” that is up for sale somewhere (such as Godaddy’s domain name auctions, Namejet, or another domain auction), then you really need to do your homework before you buy the domain name or even think of bidding on it. Domain names can be very pricey nowadays, well into the thousands of dollars, or even more than that. Here is how to evaluate an expired domain name for “SEO Value”. Search Engine Optimization Value of a domain name is different than what you might actually pay for a domain name. SEO Value includes the links and anything else that might help that domain name rank better in the search engines.

Once you have found an expired domain that you’re considering, there are several things you can do that will give you an indication of whether or not you should purchase it or not:

Look at the Backlinks

Look at the backlinks pointing to that expired domain name. You need to look at all of the links, especially like links to internal pages and subdomains. Many people make a mistake and only look at the links to the home page of a domain name–oftentimes there are more links to the domain’s other pages. Use a tool such as Majestic.com to look at all of the backlinks. Years ago, Yahoo! used to give use that link data, like I’m showing below. However, Yahoo! doesn’t give this data to us anymore, you’ll have to use a tool like Majestic to look at the accurate link data.

Manually Review Links

Manually look at the links. You have to manually go look to see if links are still there. Oftentimes it might show that a link is there but when you actually go look then the link may have been removed or even worse: the link is to another domain name. If the link is not on the page (and you think it probably should be), examine all the links on the page to see if the domain was possibly redirected to another domain name at some point. Sometimes someone will own two domain names (domain1 and domain2). Domain1.com is their main website and they bought Domain2.com and redirected it to Domain1.com. If you go look at Domain2.com, it might look like the domain has links: but it really doesn’t, it’s just is showing the links to Domain1.com. You can use a website crawler like Screaming Frog’s SEO Spider to look at the links, SF will check to see if the link is still actually there.

Are Links from One Domain?

Look at the links to see if they’re all from one domain. If a domain name has 30,000 links from one message board (a footer link?), then that’s not as good as 30,000 links from 1000 different domain names. Look at the links to determine if they’re all from a few sites or if they’re from lots of different websites. Determine if those links will go away at some point or if they’re likely to stick around for a while. If you end up buying the domain name will other site owners linking to that domain name remove the links to you?

Is Domain Indexed in Search Engines

Look to see if the domain name is still indexed in Google. Search for the domain name (put the domain name in the search box). The first result should be the domain you’re looking for. If it’s not, then investigate it further to see if there’s an issue. If the domain name does not show up, search for the domain name in “quotes” (e.g., “domain.com”). This will show you where the domain name is mentioned on other sites, indicating that there may be some links.

Which Pages are Indexed?

It’s important to take a look to see exactly which pages are indexed in the search engine results. For example, use site: search operator to find the pages indexed. Search Google for site:domain.com to see the pages that are indexed. If it’s only one or two pages, and those appear to be landing pages or parked domain pages, such as the site’s home page, then that may be OK. If there are a lot of weird pages, full of off-topic references such as adult keywords, brand names, or pills references, then it could have a problem: there could have been spam on the domain name/website previously. If the domain has a live website, be sure that the pages indexed in the search engines are, in fact, appropriate content on the site.

View the Website and Domain Name’s History

Look at the old archive.org versions of the site. If the archive.org versions redirect to another domain name then that might be an indication that you don’t really want to buy the domain name. If the old site had off-topic content on it you might not want it (domain about horses but it used to have Viagra content on it?).

What Are Your Plans?

Determine what you want to do with the domain name. If you are going to use the domain name and put content on it, then great; if the domain name has “on topic” links then that may help your search engine rankings in the future. Or, it could just have a good amount of visitors coming from other websites (referrals).

Years ago, as SEOs, we used to look for other indications of SEO Value of the domain (other than links in general) would be the TLD of the link (.edu, .gov, etc.) whereas .gov links tend to hang around for a while and may be more trusted than other types of links, and the PageRank of the link (PageRank isn’t a public number or calculation anymore, though). Now, values such as Majestic.com’s Trust Flow and Citation Flow may indicate some value–the higher the Trust Flow the better. The lower the Citation Flow the better.

Other Considerations

Another consideration, though, is whether or not you need to let the domain name “age” or not (once you buy it). You might want to consider buying the domain name, putting up a basic web page on that domain name, and let the search engines re-index it. Let them find the links again and reindex the domain name, let the PR show up in the toolbar, and perhaps get a few more links. Let it “age” for a month or two before you decide to redirect it to your current domain name. This is very helpful, especially if a domain name isn’t currently in the Google index (perhaps it fully dropped?) or the domain name only has a few links and not much PageRank. By putting new content on it (but related to the old site’s content), you might be able to get some more “SEO Value” back to the domain name. It may be helpful for you to look at what the domain name had on it before by looking at the archive.org versions of the old website.

Website Value

Put a value on the links. Every link has potential value. What would it cost you to purchase the links on an annual basis? Every link (even bad ones) would probably have a value of at least $3 to $5 each. If there are 1000 links from lots of domain names then consider the fact that it really could be worth $3000 or more. Some advertising listings that are links could have cost hundreds of dollars per year (when they were offering that option). Some links (.edu, .gov) are priceless and you cannot purchase them. Or can you?

What’s the bottom line? When you consider purchasing an older domain name or any domain name that has already been “used” or one that has already had a website on it, you really need to be careful. Look at its history. Make sure it doesn’t have any links that you wouldn’t be proud of. And make sure that the links are still there if you’re buying the domain name for links: and always use a 301 Permanent Redirect when redirecting.

If you don’t have the time or expertise to look at link data and other important data about a domain name, you might consider Hartzer Consulting’s domain background check service that will do this for you. You can also learn more about domain name due diligence by viewing the interview I did with Domain Sherpa. Another good resource is our article about how to know if you should renew your domain name, which has been recently updated.

Domain Name Background Check Service

If you don’t have the time or expertise to fully evaluate a domain name before you purchase it, Hartzer Consulting’s domain name background check service can help. For as little as $99, we can perform a thorough domain name background check on the domain name. Contact us for more information; we usually can have all of the information you need within a several hours.

Ongoing Monthly SEO Services

While Hartzer Consulting specializes in technical SEO audits of websites, we also provide SEO consulting services, on a retainer basis. We always prefer to begin all new projects with a technical SEO audit to find out the issues that need to be addressed. Contact us today to find out more about our monthly SEO services and how we can help you reach the goals for your website.